Rahasia Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Gacor Profit Besar Mahjong Wins 3 Top508 Pola Bandar Terbongkar Auto Cuan Strategi Menang Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Jitu Top508 Pola Rahasia Mahjong Wins 3 Top508 Teknik Auto Profit Pola Mahjong Wins 3 2024 Trik Ampuh Raih Profit Top508 Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Top508 Buka Rahasia Bandar Menang Mudah RTP Mahjong Wins 3 Top508 Pola Bandar Paling Akurat Rahasia Menang Mahjong Wins 3 Top508 Pola Terbukti Gacor Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Top508 Terbaru untuk Profit Maksimal Strategi Mahjong Wins 3 Top508 Bocoran Pola Terbaik Rahasia Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Gacor Menang Besar Tanpa Rugi Strategi Ampuh Menang Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Jitu Top508 Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Terbaik Rahasia Sistem Bandar Top508 Terungkap Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Top508 Kalahkan Strategi Bandar Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Rahasia Sukses Menang Besar Top508 Jackpot Mahjong Wins 3 Top508 Pola Rahasia Menang Konsisten Mahjong Wins 3 Gampang Menang Pola Terbaik Pemain Pro Top508 Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Paling Gacor Rahasia Keuntungan Besar Top508 Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Paling Akurat Rahasia Auto Profit Top508 Cara Ampuh Menang Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Gacor Maximal Cuan Top508 Mahjong Wins 3 Akun Pro Server Kamboja Modal 100K Jadi 12 Juta Mahjong Wins 3 Rekor Top508 Akun Pro Server Indonesia Modal 100K Raih 14 Juta Kejutan Mahjong Wins 3 Andi Ubah 100K Jadi 18 Juta Mahjong Wins 3 Jackpot Top508 Akun Pro Server Indonesia Siska Raih 11 Juta Mahjong Wins 3 Budi Untung 13 Juta Top508 Akun Pro Server Kamboja Mahjong Wins 3 Jackpot 17 Juta Akun Pro Server Indonesia Mahjong Wins 3 On Fire Bayu Untung 16 Juta Top508 Kamboja Rizky Untung 19 Juta Mahjong Wins 3 Akun Pro Server Indonesia Top508 Geger Mahjong Wins 3 Fajar Untung 10 Juta Akun Pro Server Kamboja Mahjong Wins 3 Meledak Dinda Untung 13 Juta Top508 Akun Pro Server Indonesia Musim Hujan Main Gates of Olympus Ngopi Surya Afdol Top508 Dua Tiga Buah Nangka Main Wild Bandito Top508 Menang Jadi Sultan Game Asik Bikin Ketagihan Nambah Saldo Dana RTP Live Top508 Fitur WhatsApp Bantu Kamu Dapat Saldo Gopay Cuma-Cuma Top508 HP Xiaomi Fitur Baru Browsing Mahjong Ways Budget Hemat Penemuan Ilmuwan Eropa RTP Live Winrate 99.9% Gates of Olympus Mahjong Ways Shortcut Keyboard 2 Tombol Jadi Jutawan Modal 50 Ribu Mahjong Ways 3 5 Sosok Bikin Gempar Mahjong Ways 2 Penemuan Scatter Hitam 7 Trick Kaya Mendadak Modal Rebahan Main Mahjong Ways 2 Modal 10 Ribu Main Mahjong Ways Hasilkan Jutaan RTP Live Terbaru Strategi Jitu Gates of Olympus Jackpot Beruntun Waktu Singkat Rahasia Pro Player Pola Trik Wild Bandito Modal Receh Panen Cuan Mahjong Ways Pola Scatter Rahasia Jarang Diketahui Menang Besar Cara Cerdas Nambah Saldo Dana Setiap Hari Main Game Seru Bosan Rebahan? Coba Game Ini Bonus Jutaan Rupiah Gabut di Rumah? Main Mahjong Ways Viral Modal Kecil Cuan Gede Game dengan Fitur Rahasia Menang Berkali-kali Tanpa Modal Besar Trik Mahjong Ways 3 Terbukti Auto Sultan Menang Besar Dapat Saldo Dana Gratis dari Game Favoritmu, Cara Ampuh! Bonus Puluhan Juta, Trik Waktu Main Gates of Olympus Viral Best808 Rahasia Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Paling Gacor Profit Tanpa Rugi Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Akurat Best808 Jackpot Besar Tiap Hari Strategi Jitu Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Rahasia Best808 Menang Besar Mahjong Wins 3 Gacor 2024 Rahasia Pola Bandar Best808 Menang Konsisten Bocoran Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Akurat Teknik Rahasia Best808 Profit Tiap Hari Modal 2 Juta Jadi 100 Juta Rahasia Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Best808 Modal 500 Ribu Jadi 30 Juta Pola Rahasia Mahjong Wins 3 Best808 Spektakuler Menang 80 Juta Modal 2 Juta Pola Jitu Mahjong Wins 3 Best808 Modal 1 Juta Jadi 50 Juta Pola Gacor Mahjong Wins 3 Best808 Rekor Menang 300 Juta Modal 5 Juta Pola Rahasia Mahjong Wins 3 Best808 Pemain Mahjong Ways Beli Motor Modal Ngopi Main Game Ngopi di Bandung Main Mahjong Ways Kafe Hidden Gem Cozy Liburan Santai Villa Main Mahjong Ways Trik Liburan Seru Main Wild Bandito Wisata Kuliner Jogja Rahasia Cuan Perjalanan Kuliner Surabaya Trik Jackpot Gates of Olympus Pulang Bawa Cuan Pemain Mahjong Wins 3 Modal 1 Juta Jadi 100 Juta TOL777 Pemain Mahjong Wins 3 Modal 500 Ribu Jackpot 50 Juta TOL777 Modal Kecil Untung Besar Mahjong Wins 3 TOL777 75 Juta Kemenangan Fantastis Mahjong Wins 3 TOL777 150 Juta Modal 3 Juta Jackpot Fantastis Mahjong Wins 3 TOL777 200 Juta Modal 1 Juta Modal 100K Menang 20J Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Gacor 150K Menang 30J Mahjong Wins 3 Modal 200K Menang 50J Mahjong Wins 3 Rahasia Pola 100K Menang 10J Mahjong Wins 3 Strategi 150K Menang 25J Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Terbukti 200K Menang 40J Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Gacor 100K Menang 15J Mahjong Wins 3 Rahasia 100K Jadi 35J Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Jitu 150K Menang 45J Mahjong Wins 3 Strategi 200K Menang 60J Mahjong Wins 3 Rahasia Bandar Gacor Mahjong Wins 3 Strategi Jitu Mahjong Wins 3 Cara Menang Besar Mahjong Wins 3 Bocoran Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Gacor Terungkap Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Strategi Akurat Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Gacor 2024 Main Mahjong Wins 3 Profit Harian Bandar Ketar-Ketir Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Profit Konsisten Rahasia Jackpot Mahjong Wins 3 Tol777 Trik Mahjong Wins 3 Tol777 Auto Cuan Pantai Iran Merah Mahjong Wins 3 Viral Jackpot Fantastis Mahjong Wins 3 Tol777 Jamaah Tarawih Kabur Mahjong Wins 3 Viral Main Mahjong Wins 3 Sultan Bongkar Trik Pengendara Bonceng Pocong Mahjong Wins 3 Mahjong Wins 3 Best808 Gacor Cuan Fantastis Cewek Viral Mahjong Wins 3 Best808 Trik Jitu Mahjong Wins 3 Best808 Jadi Pro Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Terakurat Rahasia Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Terbaik Menang Konsisten Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Paling Gacor Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Bandar Pakai Strategi Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Raih Jackpot Mahjong Wins 3 Rahasia Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Paling Jitu Bandar Curang Mahjong Wins 3 Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Jitu Pola Mahjong Wins 3 Gacor Strategi Mahjong Wins 3 Mahjong Wins 3 Gacor Cara Menang Mahjong Wins 3 Liburan Puncak Bogor Bakso Beranak Gates of Olympus Jackpot Kafe Instagramable Bandung Main Mahjong Ways 2 Malioboro Gudeg Legendaris Main Sweet Bonanza Mie Ayam Solo Energi Positif Jackpot Gates of Olympus Pantai Kuta Main Starlight Princess Jackpot Kuliner Malam Semarang Main Mahjong Ways 3 Warung Kopi Jogja Jackpot Gates of Olympus Main Mahjong Ways 2 Hujan Winrate 70 Persen Gunung Bromo Main Sweet Bonanza Saldo Meledak Alun-Alun Malang Main Wild Bandito Pentol Pedas Pedagang Cakwe Surabaya Main Mahjong Ways Jackpot Pasar Senen Menang Gates of Olympus Danau Toba Main Mahjong Ways Sunset Gacor Starlight Princess Lagu Didi Kempot Jackpot Main Mahjong Ways Pagi Hari Ngopi Jackpot Dingin Hujan Main Gates of Olympus Auto JP Modal Receh Auto Sultan Secepat Tukang Parkir Main Wild Bandito Saldo Nambah Sendiri Fitur WA Rahasia Dapat Saldo Gopay HP Kentang Bukan Masalah Xiaomi Manuskrip Kuno Bongkar Kunci Winrate 99% Dua Shortcut Keyboard Auto Sultan Bocoran Orang Dalam Trik Gacor Rebahan? 7 Trik Bikin Dompet Tebal Isi 10K Mahjong Ways Saldo Puluhan Juta
  • pagcor slot
  • pagcor slot online
  • tol777
  • slot tol777
  • tol777
  • slot tol777
  • tol777
  • slot tol777
  • rom88
  • slot rom88
  • The Law of Unintended Consequences: The Case of Proxy Advisory Firms

    The SEC requires all institutional investors to vote on all matters put forth in proxy statements, or the measures voted on during shareholder meetings. For most institutional investors, keeping up with all of these issues is not feasible, so they turn to proxy advisory firms.

    Proxy advisory firms help institutional investors wade through the overwhelming numbers of measures, and two proxy advisory firms, ISS (an arm of Genstar, a private equity firm) and Glass Lewis (an arm of the Ontario Teacher’s Pension Plan Board and the Alberta Investment Management Corporation) control 97 percent of the proxy advisory market.

    The rule was supposed to protect shareholders’ interests but, as the SEC roundtable scheduled for today recognizes, the growing clout of proxy advisory firms has raised concerns that unintended, and adverse, consequences have resulted. The advice proxy advisory firms provide regarding environmental, social, and corporate governance (ESG) programs exemplifies the problems. The goal of ESG programs is to explicitly account for issues that some people believe are important and want to promote, which sometimes comes at the expense of financial returns.

    Both ISS and Glass Lewis sponsor ESG programs; consequently, the firms have a preordained belief that pro-ESG proxy statements should be supported. Thus, their advice has clear bias on ESG issues that is not adequately disclosed. ESG criteria also raises fiduciary responsibility questions for institutional investors that the proxy advisory firms fail to fully appreciate.

    From the perspective of the individual investor, voting in favor of specific ESG programs can make sense. Perhaps the ESG program will enhance profits, perhaps it won’t. Either way, individual investors know the constraints they are imposing, and bear the consequences from their actions.

    This nexus does not hold for institutional investors, particularly public pension funds because pensioners typically have no other investment options – if you are a teacher in California, CalSTRS will manage your pension, you have no choice. Since public pension funds represent many individuals, it is inevitable that ESG policies and investing preferences will clash. For example, there is a growing push for CalPERS to divest from fossil fuel companies even though 67 percent of members surveyed by Spectrem Group in 2018 stated that the sector “is an essential element of a balanced, diversified portfolio”.

    Further, many studies that have examined ESG (see here or here) have found that automatically screening out investment options, or imposing uneconomic constraints, harms financial results. SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce expressed these concerns at the 2018 Annual SEC Conference stating that: “the problems arise when those making the investment decisions are doing so on behalf of others who do not share their ESG objectives.…When a pension fund manager is making the decision to pursue her moral goals at the risk of financial return, the manager is putting other people’s retirements at risk.”

    The large unfunded liabilities of public sector pension funds worsen these costs.

    Take California as an example. As newly-elected CalPERS Board member Jason Perez estimated, the CalPERS ESG program toward tobacco cost the retirement fund $8 billion, which is sizable relative to California’s current unfunded liabilities of nearly $170 billion according to the Pew Charitable Trusts.  The problem may even be worse than that.  As I recently reported in my chart-book on California’s pension crisis, total public employee pension debt is really closer to $1 trillion using a more realistic market estimate.

    The large fiscal hole leaves Californians with few good choices. If the state raises taxes, it would reduce overall economic prosperity, but if it fails to fully fund their pension obligations, then future public sector retirees will suffer greater economic insecurity. Given these difficult trade-offs, any policy that limits the public pension systems’ investment options, and costs potential returns, worsens California’s pension crisis.

    Combining the potential investment losses with the diversity of opinions regarding contentious social issues, it is clear that ESG investing is inappropriate for public pension funds. However, it is unclear that either ISS or Glass Lewis account for the specific needs of public pension funds when advising institutional investors about ESG proxy statements. In fact, based on their own ESG programs, it is reasonable to conclude that both firms are biased toward supporting such programs despite the clear negative impact these policies have on public pension funds.

    Without reforms that better align the interests of the proxy advisory firms and the interests of fund shareholders, these unnecessary costs will persist. To address the problems, several reforms are necessary.

    For example, instead of assuming that the analyses of proxy advisory firms are objective, or allowing the proxy advisory firms to rely on their “general conflict of interest” statements, the SEC should require conflict of interest disclosures that are specific to the issue under evaluation. More relevant conflict of interest disclosures will help ensure that the investors relying on the proxy firms’ recommendations are aware of the proxy firm’s specific biases and potential conflicts of interest as it relates to the specific issue under consideration.

    The SEC should also consider eliminating the requirement that institutional investors vote on all items on corporate proxy statements. Enabling institutional investors to focus on only those corporate proxy statements they deem material would reduce the artificial demand for the proxy advisory services, and therefore improve the competitive environment.

    Without such reforms, while unintentional, the current proxy process will continue to create additional, and unnecessary, risks for investors.

    Nothing contained in this blog is to be construed as necessarily reflecting the views of the Pacific Research Institute or as an attempt to thwart or aid the passage of any legislation.